Mikey's Pizza Reviews, Ratings & Menu | 611 3rd St, Crested Butte

General Info

Nestled right on 611 3rd St in Crested Butte, CO, Mikey's Pizza serves up an authentic, no-fuss pizza experience that’s perfect for locals and visitors alike. From the moment you walk in, the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough and sizzling toppings sets the stage for a casual, fun dining experience. If you’re in the mood for something classic, the Hamburger Pepperoni Pizza is a standout, loaded with savory toppings that balance perfectly with a soft, chewy crust. For those who love a hearty portion, the Large Slice of Pizza is a satisfying choice that delivers generous flavor with every bite, making it a go-to for a quick lunch or a late-afternoon snack.

The atmosphere at Mikey's Pizza is laid-back and family-friendly, with plenty of space for groups, making it a great spot to gather with friends or bring the kids along. Families will appreciate the accommodating vibe, while dog owners can enjoy the option to have their furry friends outside, keeping everyone happy. The restaurant also accepts reservations, which is a helpful perk during peak hours or busy weekends when the locals and tourists alike flock here for a quick bite.

Onsite services are designed for convenience without sacrificing quality. Whether you’re stopping by for a casual meal or a speedy takeout, the friendly staff ensures that every order is handled promptly and accurately. The menu, while focused on pizza, also offers creative twists and combinations that make each visit feel fresh and exciting. Reviews from the area often highlight the consistent flavors and the welcoming, relaxed environment, reinforcing Mikey's Pizza as a reliable choice for satisfying cravings in Crested Butte.

Adding to its appeal, the location is easy to find and fits seamlessly into the downtown vibe, making it an ideal spot to drop in after a day exploring the surrounding mountains or shopping around town. Whether you’re indulging in a gooey slice with friends or grabbing a quick bite solo, Mikey's Pizza balances quality and comfort effortlessly. The casual, approachable setting ensures that everyone from families to solo diners can enjoy the experience without feeling rushed, creating an atmosphere that feels both lively and relaxed.

With its combination of hearty signature dishes, friendly onsite services, and a welcoming space that even your canine companion can enjoy outside, Mikey's Pizza has firmly earned its spot as a favorite pizza destination in Crested Butte, providing a genuine, satisfying experience with every visit.

What customers say?

“ The pizza was absolutely delicious. It is off the main drag. Worth it! Customer service is amazing. Can’t miss this place ”

- Kira Z -

“ Mikey's is a great place for pizza if you are visiting Crested Butte. They have pizza, calzones, subs and salads. It is a little place so there is no seating inside, but there are a couple of tables outside yo sit and eat at. Pizza was great, we went with pepperoni. We also ordered a gangster sub which was good too and everything was ready in 15 mins. Great way to end our trip in Crested Butte! ”

- Melissa Newton -

“ This location is a walk up and order pizza establishment. I was very happy to eat here twice in one day. The first order was perfect. The dough was NY style very large,tasty, and crispy. I wanted more so after my event in town, I ordered a to-go (large garden salad, pepperoni roll, spinach roll, cheesesteak sandwich, extreme cheesesteak sandwich). I did not receive my entree a large dinner salad. Thankfully my family shared their sandwiches which both were delicious. The pepperoni roll was very doughy. Though the spinach roll was delicious. ”

- Kyle Hanks -

“ A go-to stop in CB. Slices are great, sandwiches fantastic, never disappointed in six years of stopping in! ”

- Matthew Landon -

“ Mixed feelings on my order. They offer pizza slices and this was incredible, best pizza I’ve had in CB. I got a pepperoni pizza roll which was a nice side dish and good portion. The chicken parm sandwich I was most excited for but it was relatively pricey, and had almost zero chicken on it, like one chicken nuggets worth on the whole sandwich. And the sandwich was smaller than the pasta salad that it comes with and smaller than the pizza roll. Nonetheless I will 100% be back here every time I come to CB! Just won’t be ordering the sandwiches ”

- Kevin Eassa -

“ amazing pizza, big slices with a lot of toppings. Absolutely love their pasta salad and cheesesteak as well! ”

- A. Selçuk -

“ We absolutely loved Mikey’s Pizza; we ended going twice. The best pizza in Crested Butte. The first night there, my husband forgot his drink so we drove all the way back 3 min before closing and they were kind enough to open the door right before they locked up. The ingredients are perfect and the sauce is amazing. Definitely a thumbs up, check it out if you’re ever in Crested Butte. ”

- Marlene Vazquez -

“ Pizza: phenomenal. Burritos: need work, let that bacon get crispy please! It’ll give a much needed boost in savory flavor ”

- Phil Salmeron -

Welcome to Mikey's Pizza

General Info

Mikey's Pizza menu

Mikey's Pizza Photos

What customers say?

Location & Contact

See more food places